A Theory of Truth

Hauerwas has often insisted that if we need a theory of truth to know Jesus, we should worship that theory. Jonathan Tran, a follower of Hauerwas' approach to theology, here provides us with a theory of truth that is at once both a "theory" and yet not - it is but an observation arising out of our ordinary forms of life:

 "The contexts which grant meaning to what we say go before us, necessitating “I mean what we all mean when I say something we all understand,” making speech at once an act of agency and participation. Yet agreement also incurs estrangement because while I must mean what we all mean when I say something, I sometimes don'tmean what we all mean by it. The same facts of language that gather us, that norm us, can also estrange us from one another, make us abnormal to one another. In the second sense, conventions are not unnatural intrusions on human life but rather indicative of and appropriate to what it is to be human, to be able to carry on the way that humans do, to participate in the human form of life.45 Language is conventional to the life form humans inhabit and so its conventions are natural for those whose interests in the world match the ways they speak of it and indeed how they live it. Conventions signal relations of agreement, even intimacy—what I have called internality—between words and world. We could say that we are here furnished with a theory of truth, if we can also admit that we are here furnished with its unnecessity—a theory of truth only becomes necessary when words and world are envisioned as separately occurring entities."

 (From: Jonathan Tran, "Linguistic Theology: Completing Postliberalism's Linguistic Task," Modern Theology vol. 33, 2017.)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

And they saw the place

Sermon preached at St. Margaret's Anglican on August 21, 2022. Appointed readings:  Jer 1:4-10; Ps 71:1-6; Heb 12:18-29 Introduction If you have a Bible with you this evening, it may be helpful to have it handy as this will be one of those sermons that a friend of mine once described as “A Bible in one hand and more Bible in the other.” Now, I am far from a Greek scholar as my seminary transcripts can attest to, and I generally have a rule against appealing to biblical languages in the pulpit. But, just this once, I want to draw your attention to a little bit of text criticism as our way into our epistle reading this evening.   Our lesson from Hebrews begins “You have not come to something that can be touched, a blazing fire, and darkness, and gloom, and a tempest… etc.” But what is this “something” that is being referred to? The Book of Hebrews, true to its name, sets out to explicate the gospel of Jesus Christ by way of a close reading of the Hebrew scriptures. With tha...
Read more

Unsettling Settled Stories

One of the great coups of the modern world is its success in convincing us that we have no stories except the stories we chose when we had no stories. Beyond the fact that this is itself a story, the amount of storied infrastructure necessary to sustain this story is quite remarkable. Today, I want to unsettle one of the many stories that is largely a matter of settled "fact" in contemporary discourse. My purpose here is not simply to overturn the story, but rather to complicate it sufficiently in order that we can at least begin to question its settled nature and see just how silly some of our unquestioned assumptions can be. Today's story began, as near as I can tell, with the 1967 essay by Lynn White Jr., in the journal Science   "The Historical Roots of our Ecologic Crisis." This essay is widely cited as a short-hand for blaming Christian anthropocentrism for our current environmental and ecological woes. Often, it seems that the people who cite this es...
Read more

Sin and its Liberal Deniers

The US elections loom above everything these days. There is a profound anxiety and exhaustion present in even the most ordinary public encounters. If this is the state of things in Canada, I can only imagine what our neighbours to the south are going through. Everyone seems to be holding their breath and shaking their heads, hoping that somehow things will turn out alright, knowing that even the best possible outcome is still quite terrifying. How did things get like this? How did a man who is objectively incompetent and singularly unsuited for elected office come this close to becoming the next President of the United States and the most powerful man in the world? While most liberal elites will shrug their shoulders and tell some story about the "uneducated whites" who form Trump's base, the answer is both more simple and more nuanced than that. The basic liberal belief is that education can and will solve all of society's problems. Lost your job? Re-educate yourse...
Read more